Home Students Corner Jonathan's Observations Are there really too many immigrants?

By: Jonathan Patterson

London, 21st July 2014 

On the 15th and 16th July BBC One broadcast a two-part programme titled Nick and Margaret: Too Many Immigrants?’. As can be suggested from the title, the programme was based around the issue of immigration in Britain.  It aimed to explore whether the ongoing mass immigration in Britain really is such a major problem in the country.  As a way of identifying whether an issue existed they paired up a group of British-born people, who were sceptical of or against immigration, with individual immigrants who had come from all around the world.  After spending a week with each other, the British had to decide whether immigration was indeed a “gain” or a “drain” on Britain. Some of the main issues that were covered included inequality

  • in employment,
  • inequality in housing opportunities,
  • segregation and isolation in the community,
  • inability to embrace British values, language barriers, and
  • exploitation of benefits and the National Health Service.

This ongoing stance of anti-immigration, and the belief that immigration is more negative than it is positive, is largely due to the media’s portrayal and negative focus on immigration.  For years the media has created an impression that when things appear to be wrong in society (high unemployment, declining British values etc.), it is usually immigration that is at the root of the problem.  Initially, it was quite clear that the British people who had feelings that were against immigration were likely to have been influenced and inspired by the media. Consequently, they had very little personal knowledge of immigration themselves, shown by their lack of interaction with immigrants.

The programme actually showed that after spending time with their partnered immigrants and observing them in their homes, communities and workplaces that their perceptions and viewpoints on immigration had actually changed from how they felt before meeting them.  This was shown by all of them deciding that the immigrants that they were partnered up with were more of a “gain” to British society and the economy than a “drain”.

 “If immigration had not taken place in Britain the way that it has it would be difficult to really imagine what the country would be like today. ”

When it comes to immigration in Britain it is always important to remember the impacts that the British Empire once had on the rest of the world.  Moreover, current immigration is actually an indirect impact of the influence of the British Empire.  At the peak of Empire, the British went around the world and planted many influences which impacted language, religion, culture, ideology, values and education in addition to a giant list of many other factors that still shape how the world is today.  Furthermore, this was also done whilst the British exploited resources and changed the nature of hundreds of people, communities and civilisations around the world.  This isn’t a history lesson, but it is always important to remember these issues when bringing up immigration within Britain.

Participant's in BBC's Too Many Immigrants? programme

Participant’s in BBC’s Too Many Immigrants? programme

From a more personal experience, my grandparents arrived in Britain from Jamaica in the mid-1950s whilst Jamaica was still part of the British Empire.  My grandparents saw Britain as the mother country as well as a land of hope and opportunity.  I believe that even then – and since – they have been a significant “gain” to British society:  They settled in and integrated with their local community well, and worked for the entirety of their working lives in the country.  Furthermore, by starting a family and having children and grandchildren, they have continued their legacy and continued to indirectly contribute towards Britain.

There are many perspectives around immigration and many viewpoints on either side of the fence that are for and against it.  Although, it may partially be related to the cause of some problems in the country, I believe it is wrong to put blame on immigrants as a major cause of ongoing issues that the country faces.  Moreover, the positives can be seen to outweigh many of the negatives associated with it.  Since, and even before, my grandparents both arrived to the country; immigration has brought so many great things ranging from a wide variety of cultures, economic advancement, the rebuilding of Britain and simply a wider understanding and tolerance of different people. Also, how could we ignore all the great food! If immigration had not taken place in Britain the way that it has it would be difficult to really imagine what the country would be like today.  As a result, I am a strong believer in the idea that immigration is generally something that leads to greater “gain”.

SIMILAR ARTICLES